• 中文核心期刊
  • 中国科技核心期刊
  • CSCD来源期刊
  • DOAJ 收录
  • Scopus 收录

钨矿石和锡矿石化学成分分析能力验证结果评价和离群值原因

Evaluation of the Analytical Results of Tungsten and Tine Ores in the Proficiency Testing Program

  • 摘要: 金属矿产的勘查、评价、开发与综合利用要求对不同矿石品位与精矿的完整系列品质进行评价检测和仲裁测试.钨矿石和锡矿石作为金属矿的重要矿种, 在客观上要求相关实验室应具备不同含量品级钨矿石和锡矿石组分的检测能力.本文按照国家认证认可监督委员会(CNCA)编号为CNCA-13-A14的钨矿石和锡矿石化学成分分析能力验证计划的要求, 对中国30个省市、自治区的58个实验室提供的8个元素(W、Sn、Cu、Pb、Zn、Mo、Sb、Bi)的测定结果进行能力验证分析, 采用稳健统计法, 根据Z比分数判定参加实验室的检测能力.根据Z比分数≤2为满意结果的判定标准, 51个实验室全部结果的Z比分数≤2, 总体结果满意率(各元素的Z比分数均≤2的实验室占总实验室的比例)为88%, 出现可疑和离群结果的实验室占12%.总体上钨矿石和锡矿石中元素Sb、Pb、Zn的满意率较高(其中锡矿石的Zn测定结果全部满意), W、Bi稍差; 钨矿石各元素的检测水平差异小, 整体结果好于锡矿石.钨矿石和锡矿石分析能力验证结果产生离群值的原因, 一方面是实验室的测试水平存在差异; 另一方面是各实验室采用的检测方法分散, 有化学分析方法和仪器分析方法, 化学分析方法检测步骤多, 仪器分析方法方便快速, 逐渐成为例行检测方法, 两类方法的影响因素都较多.本文提出, 提高实验室的检测水平和检测能力, 需要适当统一检测方法, 提高方法掌握的熟练程度, 避免仪器状态对分析结果的影响, 确保检测结果的一致性和准确性.

     

    Abstract: According to the proficiency testing program (CNCA-13-A14) held by the National Certification and Accreditation Committee of China (CNCA), analytical data for W, Sn, Cu, Pb, Zn, Mo, Sb and Bi in tungsten and tin ores provided by 58 analytical laboratories in 30 provinces and autonomous regions were evaluated. Robust statistics, an international general statistical method, and Z-scores were used for evaluating the testing ability of the laboratories. According to the criteria for satisfactory results (Z-scores ≤2), the overall satisfaction rate for 58 laboratories was 88% (51 laboratories) and 12% of laboratories had suspect and outlier results. As a whole, the satisfaction rate for Sb, Pb and Zn in tungsten and tin ores was high, among which all of the analytical results of Zn in Tin Ores were satisfactory; results of W, Bi were slightly worse. Results of tungsten were better than those for tin ores. Moreover, the determination methods in all laboratories and the reasons for the outlier results were analyzed. The results of proficiency testing were objectively reflected for the testing ability and technical levels of the geoanalytical laboratory. Due to the determined gap among different laboratories, it was suggested that proficiency testing should be held periodically to improve the analytical ability and ensure the reliability of analytical data.

     

/

返回文章
返回